SANA response to a Scottish govt consultation on a proposed agriculture bill
Please find here the SANA Ltd response to the Scottish Govt consultation on a proposed agriculture bill.
SANA ltd response to the Marine Scotland consultation on River Gradings and on Catch and release
The SANA Ltd response to the headline consultation is available by accessing this link. This information is published jointly by the Migratory and Non-Migratory Fish Committees of SANA Ltd.
non-Migratory Fish committee report to the SANA AGM
Please find here the Non-migratory Fish Committee report to the SANA Ltd AGM, to be held on 13 March 2022
DRAFT SANA Response to river basin management plan consultation
Posted on behalf of the MFC and the NMFC, here is the SANA draft response to the SEPA consultation on the draft River Basin Management Plan. Members of the SANA Migratory and non-Migratory Fish Committees would welcome comments on this draft which should be sent to this email address, by 31 May 2021, for onward transmission to appropriate SANA colleagues.
SANA LTD Submission TO thE north of england net fisheries CONSULTATION
Please follow this link to view the SANA Ltd response to the recent North of England Net Fisheries consultation.
SANA ltd response to scottish forestry corporate plan consultation
Please follow this link to view the SANA Ltd response to the recent Scottish Forestry Corporate Plan consultation.
Migratory Fish and non-migratory fish Committees contributions to Scottish Natural Heritage's review of shooting under general licenses
The Migratory Fish Committee has contributed to Scottish Natural Heritage's review of shooting under general licenses by pointing out that no provisions have been made for protection of fish.
Salmon is a listed species under the EU Habitats Directive and, with sea trout, is not being protected by virtue of cormorants and sawbilled ducks not being included in the general licence.
We said: " Research commissioned by and/or carried by Marine Scotland, Salmon Fisheries Boards and Fisheries Trusts demonstrates that juvenile fish (smolts and parr) are heavily predated by cormorants and by sawbilled ducks during the freshwater period prior to marine migration. Salmon and sea trout stocks have been much depleted, to the extent that most rivers in Scotland (categories 2 and 3) are judged to be at risk of insufficient spawning escapement to sustain populations. For its part, the angling community has alleviated pressure by introduction of catch and release of adult fish. Such efforts are felt to be negated by failure to contain the predatory impact of these birds on the juvenile component of salmon and sea trout stocks."
The Non-Migratory Fish Committee response is here.
Salmon is a listed species under the EU Habitats Directive and, with sea trout, is not being protected by virtue of cormorants and sawbilled ducks not being included in the general licence.
We said: " Research commissioned by and/or carried by Marine Scotland, Salmon Fisheries Boards and Fisheries Trusts demonstrates that juvenile fish (smolts and parr) are heavily predated by cormorants and by sawbilled ducks during the freshwater period prior to marine migration. Salmon and sea trout stocks have been much depleted, to the extent that most rivers in Scotland (categories 2 and 3) are judged to be at risk of insufficient spawning escapement to sustain populations. For its part, the angling community has alleviated pressure by introduction of catch and release of adult fish. Such efforts are felt to be negated by failure to contain the predatory impact of these birds on the juvenile component of salmon and sea trout stocks."
The Non-Migratory Fish Committee response is here.
Willie Miller
William Miller passed away on 25th January aged 82, and was interred on 8th February in a cemetery on a west facing hill overlooking the Clyde valley where he fished for most of his life for trout and grayling.
Willie served on the committee of the United Clyde Angling Protective Association for over 60 years, and for over 30 years held various posts on SANA’s Non-Migratory Fish Committee. He had a wide knowledge of Protection Order legislation and its implementation, and when the Scottish Government asked SANA to oversee the Ministers Consultative Committee on Protection Orders Willie became its Chairman. He was a member of the Liaison Committees of both the Tay and the Earn POs, and also a keen member of the Grayling Society.
Willie had been a science teacher and encouraged his pupils to fish, taking them on expeditions to the Clyde and its tributaries, long before the current need for criminal disclosure checks. He was an elder of his church and a perfect gentleman, widely respected by all who came to know him, and last of a line of old school NMFC volunteers such as Malcolm Steen, Jimmy McAloon, Sam Waddell, and Alastair MacKellar. He gave a great deal to SANA and to Scottish angling and will be sorely missed.
The epitaph on the riverside monument at Abington to Matthew McKendrick, one of the founding fathers of UCAPA, is equally fitting to Willie.
“Fish fair and free and spare the wee anes”
Willie served on the committee of the United Clyde Angling Protective Association for over 60 years, and for over 30 years held various posts on SANA’s Non-Migratory Fish Committee. He had a wide knowledge of Protection Order legislation and its implementation, and when the Scottish Government asked SANA to oversee the Ministers Consultative Committee on Protection Orders Willie became its Chairman. He was a member of the Liaison Committees of both the Tay and the Earn POs, and also a keen member of the Grayling Society.
Willie had been a science teacher and encouraged his pupils to fish, taking them on expeditions to the Clyde and its tributaries, long before the current need for criminal disclosure checks. He was an elder of his church and a perfect gentleman, widely respected by all who came to know him, and last of a line of old school NMFC volunteers such as Malcolm Steen, Jimmy McAloon, Sam Waddell, and Alastair MacKellar. He gave a great deal to SANA and to Scottish angling and will be sorely missed.
The epitaph on the riverside monument at Abington to Matthew McKendrick, one of the founding fathers of UCAPA, is equally fitting to Willie.
“Fish fair and free and spare the wee anes”
NMFC Enquiries
The NMFC chair my be contacted by following this link.
Stocking of adult Brown Trout into Rivers and Streams update from Marine Scotland
Biosecurity for events
The GB non-native species secretariat has published new guidelines.
David Paterson
It is with great sadness that we report the passing of David on the 22nd August. A stalwart of the Non-Migratory Fish Committee for many years he was a member of Avon Angling Club and was part of the River Clyde Management Trust. A full appreciation will appear in the SANA Handbook.
CONSULTATION ON CROWN ESTATE INTERIM MANAGEMENT IN SCOTLAND
SANA's submission can be read here.
Exercise Alpheus update
Exercise Alpheus was designed to test the response to a cross border (Scotland, England and Wales) outbreak of Gyrodactylus salaries. The update on the outcomes can be read here.
SANA Submission to the Wild Fisheries Review Panel
The SANA submission from the NMFC to the Wild Fisheries Review Panel in respect of the consultation on the structure of governance for wild fisheries management is below;
NMFC Submission here.
NMFC Submission here.
Minutes of the N-MFC - 2 Feb 2014
The minutes of the most recent N-MFC meeting are here.
SANA's Winter Cormorant Count 2013/2014
Details of the proposed count and survey form can be found here.
SANA's Cormorant Survey
The results of the recent survey can be found here.
Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill update
There is some interesting and useful information here about the progress of the Aquaculture and Fisheries (Scotland) Bill. Any comment should be passed to the webmaster, who will forward to the relevant SANA committee.
Overburns Farm Quarry Victory
SANA is delighted to see this article in the Carluke Gazette. SANA has played a full part, primarily through the Non-Migratory Fish Committee, in opposing the plan for the establishment of a quarry at Overburns Farm. SANA has supported the Clyde River Action Group and is delighted that this planning application has been rejected for a third time. This is a fine example of the part SANA can play in the protection of the aquatic environment. Please continue to support your National Anglers Association.
Quarry at Lamington on the Clyde – Appeal
In March of this year (see below) SANA was pleased to be able to report that South Lanarkshire’s Planning Committee had unanimously voted to refuse planning permission for a massive sand and gravel quarry adjacent to the banks of the Clyde at Lamington.
However, as anticipated, Patersons have appealed, and a Reporter. Mr David Buylla MA (Hons) MRTPI has been appointed. He will conduct inquiry sessions and a hearing session in November. We have been informed that all earlier submissions will be taken into account and that Mr. Buylla feels that he already has sufficient information on all matters except “landscape and visual issues”.
SANA hopes that Mr. Buylla will reach the same conclusion as South Lanarkshire Council.
However, as anticipated, Patersons have appealed, and a Reporter. Mr David Buylla MA (Hons) MRTPI has been appointed. He will conduct inquiry sessions and a hearing session in November. We have been informed that all earlier submissions will be taken into account and that Mr. Buylla feels that he already has sufficient information on all matters except “landscape and visual issues”.
SANA hopes that Mr. Buylla will reach the same conclusion as South Lanarkshire Council.
SANA Policy on Access to Rivers by Canoeists and Rafters
The SANA policy document on access to rivers by canoeists and rafters is here.
Catch and Release Survey
We are delighted to make this document, A Survey of Catch and Release in Stocked UK Stillwater Trout Fisheries available to our members and friends. The survey may be downloaded in the form of a PDF file by clicking here. The survey has been conducted my Messrs C Vaughan Ruckley, Eric J Fox and Bob Perrett. Should any member have any comment on the survey please email the SANA webmaster who will arrange to pass any comment to the authors.
Quarry at Lamington on the Clyde - Planning Permission Refused
SANA yesterday received the following email:
I am delighted to be able to report that yesterday, Tuesday 27 March 2012, the planning committee of South Lanarkshire Council unanimously voted to refuse planning permission to SLR on behalf of Paterson's of Greenoakhill for a sand and gravel quarry adjacent to the banks of the Clyde at Lamington. This was the second application subitted by them in a 27 month period.
It was noted by the chairman that the quality and content of the objections was of a very high standard and that the campaign conducted by the umbrella group, Clyde River Action Group, was very focussed, professional and considered.
To everyone who submitted letters of objection or provided advice and support, thank you.
I am delighted to be able to report that yesterday, Tuesday 27 March 2012, the planning committee of South Lanarkshire Council unanimously voted to refuse planning permission to SLR on behalf of Paterson's of Greenoakhill for a sand and gravel quarry adjacent to the banks of the Clyde at Lamington. This was the second application subitted by them in a 27 month period.
It was noted by the chairman that the quality and content of the objections was of a very high standard and that the campaign conducted by the umbrella group, Clyde River Action Group, was very focussed, professional and considered.
To everyone who submitted letters of objection or provided advice and support, thank you.
Killer Shrimps and Beavers
Some news here on the spread of the killer shrimp to the Norfolk Broads and here is an update on the beavers in the Tay catchment area. Thanks to Alan for highlighting these issues to the webmaster.
Access and Protection - Project 6.2
Project 6.2 is one of the Priorities for Action (PfA) listed in the Government's "A Strategic Framework for Scottish Freshwater Fisheries" published in 2008. SANA was asked by the Steering Group of the Freshwater Fisheries Forum to supervise a review of the operation of existing Protection Orders (POs), with a view to incorporating their better features in a Scotland-wide system of access and freshwater fish protection. Economic cut-backs jeopardised anticipated Government finance for professional input into this project, but the Non-Migratory Fish Committee (NMFC) of SANA produced the following limited review in April 2011 using its own resources and PO reports provided by Marine Scotland (MS).
The report may be found here.
The report may be found here.
Minutes of the N-MFC - 11 Feb 2012
The minutes of the most recent N-MFC meeting are here.
Survey of Catch & Release in UK Stillwater Fisheries
SANA has been asked to make this report available on the website. This indepent study attracted participation from 198 fisheries, of which 60 were in Scotland. The report is here. Members or friends wishing to comment should do so via the webmaster.
SNH Wildlife Management Survey Feasibility Study
In early March 2012 SNH planning to launch an online questionnaire. This will be designed to tell Scottish Natural Heritage (SNH) what members of the public and those who deal with the organisation think of the way that wildlife is managed in Scotland. It is also designed to tell SNH what people who deal with the organisation think of the level of service provided. SNH hope to gather the views of a large number of people across a range of different organisations. Links to the survey will appear here in due course. In the meantime, here is the link to the SNH Wildlife Management Survey Feasibility Study.
Clyde Users Group 'Cuningar Loop' Focus Groups
We have just received this from a company called Community Links in relation to our involvement with the Clyde Users Group:
We have recently been commissioned by the Clyde Gateway and the Forestry Commission to conduct a series of focus groups regarding the development of a piece of greenbelt land at “Cuningar Loop” which is surrounded by the River Clyde
Focus groups are available to you or an alternative member of your organisation on the following days. There will be a £10 participation fee for local residents & community members:
· Tuesday 22nd November @ 7pm in the Wee Mill Pub (Farmeloan Cross, Rutherglen)
· Monday 28th November @ 11am in the Dalmarnock Community Centre (Lily Street, Dalmarnock)
Cuningar Loop is situated in the Rutherglen area and as a legacy to the Commonwealth games, the site will be developed as a Healthy Lifestyle Park/open space aimed at promoting active communities. We are looking for participants to take part in focus groups to discuss opportunities and ideas that will be passed to the architect for thought during the planning process. We recognise that due to the dominance of the river clyde in this area opinions from members of the Clyde Users Groups would be highly valued.
Please feel free to forward this as you see fit.......
We have recently been commissioned by the Clyde Gateway and the Forestry Commission to conduct a series of focus groups regarding the development of a piece of greenbelt land at “Cuningar Loop” which is surrounded by the River Clyde
Focus groups are available to you or an alternative member of your organisation on the following days. There will be a £10 participation fee for local residents & community members:
· Tuesday 22nd November @ 7pm in the Wee Mill Pub (Farmeloan Cross, Rutherglen)
· Monday 28th November @ 11am in the Dalmarnock Community Centre (Lily Street, Dalmarnock)
Cuningar Loop is situated in the Rutherglen area and as a legacy to the Commonwealth games, the site will be developed as a Healthy Lifestyle Park/open space aimed at promoting active communities. We are looking for participants to take part in focus groups to discuss opportunities and ideas that will be passed to the architect for thought during the planning process. We recognise that due to the dominance of the river clyde in this area opinions from members of the Clyde Users Groups would be highly valued.
Please feel free to forward this as you see fit.......
Non Migratory Fish Committee
SANA Non-Migratory Fish Committee
The remit of the Non Migratory Fish Committee (NMFC) is to maintain an overview of of issues and legislation that may affect non-migratory salmonids and members of SANA who fish for them; to consider problems and possible solutions and take appropriate action.
Issues are wide ranging and can take up considerable time and effort. Members are welcome to make enquiries about issues or contribute views via the NMFC secretary or the SANA office.
NMFC officials are all volunteers and their names are published in the SANA handbook which is normally published in February. Most are active in various angling spheres and all are keen anglers. We would welcome anyone who is interested in the committee's work and wants to help at the sharp end, particularly if he or she has pertinent knowledge or skills. Contact the secretary on 01324 623920 or at alan.ayre345@btinternet.com if you are interested in joining the committee.
Meetings are held bi-monthly at Howietoun fishery near Stirling on Saturday mornings.
The remit of the Non Migratory Fish Committee (NMFC) is to maintain an overview of of issues and legislation that may affect non-migratory salmonids and members of SANA who fish for them; to consider problems and possible solutions and take appropriate action.
Issues are wide ranging and can take up considerable time and effort. Members are welcome to make enquiries about issues or contribute views via the NMFC secretary or the SANA office.
NMFC officials are all volunteers and their names are published in the SANA handbook which is normally published in February. Most are active in various angling spheres and all are keen anglers. We would welcome anyone who is interested in the committee's work and wants to help at the sharp end, particularly if he or she has pertinent knowledge or skills. Contact the secretary on 01324 623920 or at alan.ayre345@btinternet.com if you are interested in joining the committee.
Meetings are held bi-monthly at Howietoun fishery near Stirling on Saturday mornings.
Fish Dumping
Overkill! Let's dump the dumping
SANA is aware of, and deplores the practice of some anglers killing fish they don't need. Such fish are often not taken home, but dumped in bins, flung behind walls, into ditches etc. It seems to occur often after competitions when fish are required to be weighed in for prize or/and place allocation. However, the bag limit culture is partly to blame too, with some everyday anglers keen to show off their "prowess" to others.
Not only is the practice reprehensible from the point of view of wasting good food, but it shows a lack of respect for the fish, and presents ammunition for the anti-fishing brigade.
What to do about it? SANA believes it is up to fishery managers to control the practice through their rules at individual fisheries, and for most competitions to be judged perhaps by the numbers or/and length of fish caught. Some fisheries are already mooting C&R in competitions, and this may grow for normal fishing as the recession bites and fish become more expensive to stock. That said, total C&R is not supported by SANA (unless it is for conservation purposes) as the need to kill fish for the table is a prime requisite of angling.
To end dumping the principal requirements are for the traditional practice of 'chapping' every fish caught to change, for anglers to show more respect for their quarry, and to only take home what you really need.
SANA is aware of, and deplores the practice of some anglers killing fish they don't need. Such fish are often not taken home, but dumped in bins, flung behind walls, into ditches etc. It seems to occur often after competitions when fish are required to be weighed in for prize or/and place allocation. However, the bag limit culture is partly to blame too, with some everyday anglers keen to show off their "prowess" to others.
Not only is the practice reprehensible from the point of view of wasting good food, but it shows a lack of respect for the fish, and presents ammunition for the anti-fishing brigade.
What to do about it? SANA believes it is up to fishery managers to control the practice through their rules at individual fisheries, and for most competitions to be judged perhaps by the numbers or/and length of fish caught. Some fisheries are already mooting C&R in competitions, and this may grow for normal fishing as the recession bites and fish become more expensive to stock. That said, total C&R is not supported by SANA (unless it is for conservation purposes) as the need to kill fish for the table is a prime requisite of angling.
To end dumping the principal requirements are for the traditional practice of 'chapping' every fish caught to change, for anglers to show more respect for their quarry, and to only take home what you really need.
Cormorants & Sawbills
Government response to letters.....
Cormorants & Sawbills
SANA sent letters to Scottish Government ministers in March 2009, April 2011 and July 2011 about the damage cormorants and sawbills are doing to freshwater fish stocks. We want the Government to take heed of and follow the lead of the English Fisheries Minister who views with some concern the worsening position south of the Border and is considering relaxing the rules on shooting.
As earlier intimated on the SANA website, the Angling Trust in England has initiated a scheme which covers the whole of the UK. Scottish anglers are asked to record on a website ( www.cormorantwatch.org ) any cormorants or sawbills they see on freshwaters with a view to providing evidence of growing numbers of these birds living foraging inland.
SNH recently assumed licensing responsibility from the Scottish Government for the shooting of cormorants and other piscivorous birds, and it is understood that they will be reviewing their licensing policy over the next 12 months. There will be a formal consultation for the submission of views, so SANA is keen to hear from members who have evidence of damage the birds are doing to stocks, and/or evidence of increasing numbers of birds on waters with which they are familiar.
Such evidence, plus views on licensing should be sent to SANA Secretary as soon as possible, by post or email - admin@sana.org.uk
Cormorants & Sawbills
SANA sent letters to Scottish Government ministers in March 2009, April 2011 and July 2011 about the damage cormorants and sawbills are doing to freshwater fish stocks. We want the Government to take heed of and follow the lead of the English Fisheries Minister who views with some concern the worsening position south of the Border and is considering relaxing the rules on shooting.
As earlier intimated on the SANA website, the Angling Trust in England has initiated a scheme which covers the whole of the UK. Scottish anglers are asked to record on a website ( www.cormorantwatch.org ) any cormorants or sawbills they see on freshwaters with a view to providing evidence of growing numbers of these birds living foraging inland.
SNH recently assumed licensing responsibility from the Scottish Government for the shooting of cormorants and other piscivorous birds, and it is understood that they will be reviewing their licensing policy over the next 12 months. There will be a formal consultation for the submission of views, so SANA is keen to hear from members who have evidence of damage the birds are doing to stocks, and/or evidence of increasing numbers of birds on waters with which they are familiar.
Such evidence, plus views on licensing should be sent to SANA Secretary as soon as possible, by post or email - admin@sana.org.uk